Differentiating learning

Differentiation refers to the responses that teachers make to learners’ needs. Effective differentiation functions on the premise that every student can do remarkable things with the appropriate guidance and support.

There are four types of classroom elements These include content process product and learning environment which can all be differentiated by teachers according to the readiness and interests and learning profile of students
Image: There are four types of classroom elements These include content process product and learning environment which can all be differentiated by teachers according to the readiness and interests and learning profile of students

Teachers are ‘differentiating’ when they:

  • provide several learning options or different paths to learning, to help students take in information and make sense of concepts and skills
  • provide appropriate levels of challenge for all students including those who are behind, those in the middle and those who are advanced.

Effective differentiation doesn't provide excuses or easy ways out, for example, teachers are not differentiating when they ‘water down’ the curriculum for students.

Teachers can differentiate through a range of instructional and management strategies. This includes classroom elements (content, process, product and learning environment) in relation to student needs (readiness, interest and learning profile).

Teachers can differentiate according to student characteristics
Image: Teachers can differentiate content, process, product and the learning environment according to the student characteristics of readiness, interests and learning profile.

In its truest sense, teaching is not finished until learning occurs – for each learner. Teaching without learning is an oxymoron. Tomlinson, 2006

Key principles

There are a number of guiding principles that reflect effective practice in a differentiated classroom, including flexibility, respect and collaboration. The key principles are:

  • A differentiated classroom is flexible: teachers and students understand that there are many classroom elements that can be used as tools to promote individual and whole-class success, such as:
    • time
    • materials
    • modes of teaching
    • ways of grouping students
    • ways of expressing learning
    • ways of assessing learning.
  • Assessment and instruction are inseparable: the teacher views everything that a student says or does as useful information to understand the learner and craft their effective instruction for that learner (differentiation of instruction stems from effective and ongoing assessment of learner needs).
  • All students participate in ‘respectful’ work: each student needs to be involved in challenging tasks that are equally interesting and engaging, to offer equal access to essential understanding and skills.
  • Students and teachers are collaborators in learning: the teacher studies their students to ascertain what works and what doesn’t work for them, and continually involves students in decision-making about the classroom (as a result students become more independent learners).
  • The teacher uses flexible grouping options: they plan student working arrangements that vary widely and purposefully often over relatively short periods of time, for example whole-class, small group and one-on-one arrangements are used (the flexible grouping of students helps ensure access to a wide variety of learning opportunities and working arrangements).
  • The teacher focuses on the essentials: they provide clarity about what is essential for students to know, understand and do.
  • The teacher modifies content, process and products: they find key opportunities to meet learners where they are ‘at’ in order to propel them forward in knowledge, understanding and skill.

Note: it is not necessary to differentiate everything all of the time.

A flexible classroom

Flexibility is at the heart of differentiation and the teacher is continually looking for ways to modify classroom elements to make learning as effective as possible for the greatest number of students.

Those elements may include time, space, groupings, materials, modes of presentation, modes of investigation, resources and instructional strategies.

Flexibility involves the teacher searching for solutions to the inevitable problems and tensions that arise when teaching complex content to a variety of students.

Assessment and instruction are inseparable

  • Student differences are expected, appreciated and studied as a basis for instructional planning.
  • The teacher knows what to do next when they recognise where students are in relation to the learning intentions/goals.
  • The teacher is primed to teach more effectively if they are aware of the students’ needs and interests.
  • Pre-assessment informs the teacher of the student status (knowledge and skill) in relation to upcoming learning intentions/goals, student interests and the students’ preferred ways of learning.
  • On-going assessment (assessment for and as learning) throughout the lesson sequence/unit sharpens the teacher’s sense of what is working and what is not yet working for all the students in the class. It enables the teacher to continue working with students in ways that target their particular strengths and needs in light of important learning intentions/goals.
  • Summative assessment (assessment of learning) should be designed to maximise student opportunity to demonstrate what they have come to know, understand and be able to do as a result of the lesson sequence/unit. It can also ‘feed forward’ to the next lesson sequence/unit so that the teacher is continuously gathering data on student growth and refining instructional plans based on the data.

All students participate in respectful work

  • The teacher’s goal is that each student finds their work challenging and interesting, and grapples squarely with the knowledge and skills which give them the power to understand, apply and progress to the next learning stage, most of the time.
  • Differentiation does not presume different tasks for each student, but rather just enough flexibility in task complexity, working arrangements and modes of learning expression that varied students find learning a good fit much of the time.

Students and teachers are collaborators in learning

  • Students need guidance in becoming self-guided learners.
  • Classrooms are more effective and inviting when responsibility for their operation is shared by all members of the learning community.
  • Students hold pivotal information about their likes and preferred ways of learning.
  • Students can learn to make choices that enhance both their learning and their status as a learner.

Flexible student grouping options

Various student groupings are possible, and sometimes students:

  • work in similar readiness groups with peers who manifest similar academic needs at a given time
  • of mixed readiness work together in settings that draw upon the strengths of each student
  • work with classmates who have like interests
  • of varied interests cooperate towards completing a task that calls on all their interests
  • work with those who have similar learning patterns (a group of auditory learners listening to a taped explanation)
  • work with students with varied learning patterns (an analytic student and a practical student) to complete a task
  • work with whoever is sitting beside them
  • count off into groups
  • draw a partner’s name
  • choose who they work with.

The teacher defines essentials

The teacher is clear about what matters in the subject matter, and:

  • provides a compass for curriculum that both engages their students and promotes understanding
  • develops work that focuses on what matters most
  • provides a basis for extending the work of students who are advanced and scaffolding the work of students who require extra support.

The teacher modifies content

The teacher modifies content, process and products in response to student readiness, interest and learning profile.

This is done by providing opportunities so students can work with content and products in ‘sense-making’ learning experiences that are responsive to the students' readiness, needs, interests and best modes of learning.

In doing this, teachers maximise the opportunities for success for each learner.

References

  • Tomlinson, C. (2006). An Educator's Guide to Differentiating instruction. USA: Cengage Learning.
  • Tomlinson, C. A., & Allan, S. D. (2000). Leadership for Differentiating Schools and Classrooms. Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development.
Return to top of page Back to top