Ideas

The selection of a series of relevant ideas to support the thesis or argument and elaborating on them is an important part of composing persuasive texts.

Students, particularly those with limited background knowledge, may require assistance in generating ideas.

Audience: Can I use my own experiences?

Strategy

Explicit teaching

Teachers need to select topics that students have some familiarity with or include activities to build field knowledge of the topic area before expecting students to generate ideas. Practice in generating ideas alone could be practised regularly especially in collaboration with others.

General strategies

Students can read texts about the topic, watch videos, interview other people and take notes. Students could conduct online surveys using Survey Monkey.

Keep an eye out for topics in the media that are relevant to students’ lives. Picture books or poems are also a good stimulus for writing. For example, ‘The Piggy Book’ by Anthony Browne could be used to discuss the need for children to help with household jobs. Listening to the poem ‘Television’ by Roald Dahl would be a good way to stimulate discussion about limiting the time children spend watching TV or using electronic devices.
www.youtube.com

There should be opportunities for students to create texts about topics they are genuinely interested in. Here is an example of a student chosen topic composed using the Bookcreator app.
www.oise.utoronto.ca/balancedliteracydiet/Recipe

Teachers can assist students to create their own blog or website to showcase their texts about topics of their choice.

Activities to support the strategy

Activity 1: taking up a position/polarised debate

Place the position cards; agree/unsure /disagree around the room. Read out a statement related to a classroom topic. Once students have thought about the statement they move to the position card that best represents their thoughts about the statement. They can be given time to share their opinion with the person next to them before sharing their views with the rest of the class.

Plus and minus chart

Add the ideas generated in the above activity to a plus and minus chart in pairs. Students can then choose the three strongest arguments to include in their persuasive text.

School hours should be extended
Plus (+) Minus (-)
School can be an escape from home for children who may have problems at home. Students would be tired and unfocused so they wouldn't be able to learn as much.
It would be more convenient for parents to pick children up after work. Teachers would be tired and grumpy. Teachers wouldn't have time to plan interesting lessons.
Children would have more opportunities to lean. Some countries that have high academic results have 5 hour school days and less homework such as Finland.
Children who have learning difficulties could receive extra tuition. Students wouldn't be able to do extra-curricular activities like sport or dance.

Consequence chart

To generate ideas students could be asked to start from an opinion and think about the consequences.

School hours should be extended:

example of brain storming chart.

www.oise.utoronto.ca

Activity 2: collecting images to stimulate ideas

Teacher models how to collect images from the internet to build the field or support an argument.

For example, for a persuasive text on the best type of pet to have, collect images of their chosen pet that could be used to generate reasons.

Images could include:

  • child with pet dog (to represent companionship).
  • policeman with dog (to represent how dogs can assist people).
  • family walking with dog in the park (having a dog encourages people to do more exercise).

Students could work in pairs to collect and label images.

Sets of images could be stored in topic folders and shared with students in other classes.

Students could add images to Powerpoint slides and then share their ideas with a partner before composing.

Recording ideas

The Bookcreator app, Powerpoint or other recording tools can be used to assist students to plan their writing and record ideas orally www.oise.utoronto.ca/balancedliteracydiet/Recipe

Activity 3: what’s the other side?

The teacher could provide ideas for one side of an issue and the students generate ideas for the other side.
As a follow up, half the class could generate ideas for one side on large sheets of paper in groups then pass their work to another group who add the ideas for the other side.

Alternatively, students who have difficulty generating ideas could be given graphic organisers that have been partially filled in. For example, the persuasion map generator from readwritethink.org www.readwritethink.org

Students could be given a range of ideas on slips of paper and asked to categorise the ideas as for or against. Some irrelevant ideas could be included for students to eliminate.

Quick writes

To increase writing fluency and stimulate rapid ideas generation students could be given a time limit to write as much as they can on a topic related to an issue. For example, write down all the ways we use plastic bags, or list all the types of food that you think are unhealthy.

References

Australian curriculum

ACELT1596: Responding to literature: Draw connections between personal experiences and the worlds of texts, and share responses with others.

NSW syllabus

EN2-11D: Outcome 11: responds to and composes a range of texts that express viewpoints of the world similar to and different from their own  (EN2-11D) - Respond to and compose texts: justify personal opinions by citing evidence, negotiating with others and recognising opinions presented

NSW literacy continuum

WRIC10M2: Aspects of writing, Cluster 10, Marker 2: Shows awareness of the need to justify opinions with supporting evidence.

Teacher resources

Texts

  • Culham, R. (2014). The writing thief: Using mentor texts to teach the craft of writing. Newark, DE: International Reading Association
  • Dorfman, L. R. & Capelli, R. (2009) Nonfiction mentor texts: Teaching informational writing through children’s literature, K-8. Portland Maine: Stenhouse Publishers.
Return to top of page